Gifts Under $500

These pieces bring a sense of luxury and joy to the season.

All Gifts

Most Gifted

Gifts Under $250

Gifts Under $500

Gifts Under $1000

Splurge Worthy

Men's Gifts

Kid's Gifts

Sort by
Category
Metal
Stones
Chain Length
Ring Size
Bracelet Size
Price
From $
To
To $
Adjustable Popcorn Chain
LAST CHANCE

Adjustable Popcorn Chain

Regular price $178.00
Sale price $178.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Adjustable Popcorn Chain is a stunning sterling silver necklace that can be worn at...
Petroglyph & Elongated Stone Drop Earrings - Larimar
BEST SELLER
11 stone options
Larimar
Hampton Blue Topaz
Blue Topaz
London Blue Topaz
Blue Chalcedony
Moonstone
White Topaz
Prasiolite
Citrine
Amethyst
Smoky Quartz

Petroglyph & Elongated Stone Drop Earrings

Regular price $298.00
Sale price $298.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Petroglyph and Elongated Stone Drop Earrings are handcrafted in sterling silver and hang gracefully...
Astrology Pendant

Astrology Pendant

Regular price $148.00
Sale price $148.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Astrology Pendant is handcrafted from sterling silver, showcasing the zodiac symbol on one side and...
Twisted St. John Map Pendant
NEW

Twisted St. John Map Pendant

Regular price $99.00
Sale price $99.00 Regular price
Unit price
Keep the island close to your heart with the Twisted St. John Map Pendant. Handcrafted...
Mini Petroglyph Hoop Earrings

Mini Petroglyph Hoop Earrings

Regular price $128.00
Sale price $128.00 Regular price
Unit price
Dainty yet unique enough to stand out in a crowd, these sterling silver hoops wrap...
Princess Petroglyph Stone Studs - London Blue Topaz
BEST SELLER
7 stone options
Larimar
Hampton Blue Topaz
London Blue Topaz
White Zircon
Green Zircon
Citrine
Amethyst

Princess Petroglyph Stone Studs

Regular price $298.00
Sale price $298.00 Regular price
Unit price
Perfect with any outfit, the Princess Petroglyph Stone Studs feature faceted London blue topaz stones...
Princess Petroglyph Twisted Bangle - Green Zircon
NEW
2 stone options
Hampton Blue Topaz
Green Zircon

Princess Petroglyph Twisted Bangle

Regular price $398.00
Sale price $398.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Princess Petroglyph Twisted Bangle is a unique design handcrafted in sterling silver with a...
Turtle Pendant with Petroglyph Texture Shell
BEST SELLER

Turtle Pendant with Petroglyph Texture Shell

Regular price $248.00
Sale price $248.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Turtle Pendant serves as a constant reminder of joyful moments by the beach. Handcrafted...
Sea Foam Larimar Pendant
BEST SELLER

Sea Foam Larimar Pendant

Regular price $498.00
Sale price $498.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Sea Foam Larimar Pendant is handcrafted with sterling silver and showcases a captivating pear-shaped...
Compass Pendant with St. John Coordinates - Blue Zircon
3 stone options
Larimar
Blue Zircon
Black Zircon

Compass Pendant with St. John Coordinates

Regular price $198.00
Sale price $198.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Compass Pendant is a great addition to your St. John inspired jewelry collection. Adorned...
Stone & Petroglyph Studs - Blue Zircon
8 stone options
Larimar
Hampton Blue Topaz
Blue Zircon
Amethyst
White Zircon
Citrine
Green Zircon
Black Onyx

Stone & Petroglyph Studs

Regular price $148.00
Sale price $148.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Stone & Petroglyph Studs, handcrafted in sterling silver, feature a brilliant faceted stone set...
Compass Pendant with St. John Coordinates - Larimar
3 stone options
Larimar
Blue Zircon
Black Zircon

Compass Pendant with St. John Coordinates

Regular price $198.00
Sale price $198.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Compass Pendant is a great addition to your St. John inspired jewelry collection. Adorned...
Mini Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant - Hampton Blue Topaz
NEW
2 stone options
Hampton Blue Topaz
Green Zircon

Mini Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant

Regular price $168.00
Sale price $168.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Mini Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant is handcrafted in sterling silver and features a faceted...
STJ Salty Dog Paw Charm

STJ Salty Dog Paw Charm

Regular price $498.00
Sale price $498.00 Regular price
Unit price
Woof! This adorable 14K solid gold Salty Dog Paw Charm features STJ on the front...
One Love Pendant with Stone - London Blue Topaz
BEST SELLER
5 stone options
Larimar
Blue Zircon
London Blue Topaz
Green Zircon
Citrine

One Love Pendant with Stone

Regular price $428.00
Sale price $428.00 Regular price
Unit price
The One Love Pendant, with a gently hammered sterling silver infinite circle, is inspired by...
Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant - London Blue Topaz
BEST SELLER
6 stone options
Larimar
Hampton Blue Topaz
London Blue Topaz
White Zircon
Green Zircon
Citrine

Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant

Regular price $268.00
Sale price $268.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant is a great addition to your jewelry collection. Handcrafted from...
« 1 … 3 4 5 6 7 … 9 »
Sort by
  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old

Elevate your holiday gift-giving with our collection of jewelry, all under $500. This selection offers sophisticated style and exceptional quality, featuring island-inspired jewelry handcrafted in sterling silver, 14K gold, oxidized silver, and stunning gemstones that are perfect for making a statement. Each piece combines timeless design with modern craftsmanship, creating gifts that are as meaningful as they are beautiful. Discover gifts that sparkle with elegance and make every holiday moment unforgettable.