Gifts Under $500

These pieces bring a sense of luxury and joy to the season.

All Valentine's Gifts

Most Gifted

Gifts Under $250

Gifts Under $500

Gifts Under $1000

Splurge Worthy

Men's Gifts

Sort by
Category
Metal
Stones
Chain Length
Ring Size
Bracelet Size
Price
From $
To
To $
Twisted St. John Map Pendant
NEW

Twisted St. John Map Pendant

Regular price $99.00
Sale price $99.00 Regular price
Unit price
Keep the island close to your heart with the Twisted St. John Map Pendant. Handcrafted...
Mini Petroglyph Hoop Earrings

Mini Petroglyph Hoop Earrings

Regular price $128.00
Sale price $128.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
Dainty yet unique enough to stand out in a crowd, these sterling silver hoops wrap...
Princess Petroglyph Stone Studs - London Blue Topaz
BEST SELLER
7 stone options
Larimar
Hampton Blue Topaz
London Blue Topaz
White Zircon
Green Zircon
Citrine
Amethyst

Princess Petroglyph Stone Studs

Regular price $298.00
Sale price $298.00 Regular price
Unit price
Perfect with any outfit, the Princess Petroglyph Stone Studs feature faceted London blue topaz stones...
Princess Petroglyph Twisted Bangle - Green Zircon
NEW
3 stone options
Hampton Blue Topaz
Green Zircon
Red Zircon

Princess Petroglyph Twisted Bangle

Regular price $398.00
Sale price $398.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Princess Petroglyph Twisted Bangle is a unique design handcrafted in sterling silver with a...
Turtle Pendant with Petroglyph Texture Shell
BEST SELLER

Turtle Pendant with Petroglyph Texture Shell

Regular price $248.00
Sale price $248.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Turtle Pendant serves as a constant reminder of joyful moments by the beach. Handcrafted...
Sea Foam Larimar Pendant
BEST SELLER

Sea Foam Larimar Pendant

Regular price $498.00
Sale price $498.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Sea Foam Larimar Pendant is handcrafted with sterling silver and showcases a captivating pear-shaped...
Compass Pendant with St. John Coordinates - Blue Zircon
3 stone options
Larimar
Blue Zircon
Black Zircon

Compass Pendant with St. John Coordinates

Regular price $198.00
Sale price $198.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Compass Pendant is a great addition to your St. John inspired jewelry collection. Adorned...
Stone & Petroglyph Studs - Blue Zircon
8 stone options
Larimar
Hampton Blue Topaz
Blue Zircon
Amethyst
White Zircon
Citrine
Green Zircon
Black Onyx

Stone & Petroglyph Studs

Regular price $148.00
Sale price $148.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Stone & Petroglyph Studs, handcrafted in sterling silver, feature a brilliant faceted stone set...
Compass Pendant with St. John Coordinates - Larimar
3 stone options
Larimar
Blue Zircon
Black Zircon

Compass Pendant with St. John Coordinates

Regular price $198.00
Sale price $198.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Compass Pendant is a great addition to your St. John inspired jewelry collection. Adorned...
Mini Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant - Hampton Blue Topaz
NEW
3 stone options
Hampton Blue Topaz
Green Zircon
Red Zircon

Mini Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant

Regular price $168.00
Sale price $168.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Mini Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant is handcrafted in sterling silver, featuring a faceted Hampton...
STJ Salty Dog Paw Charm

STJ Salty Dog Paw Charm

Regular price $498.00
Sale price $498.00 Regular price
Unit price
14K Solid Gold
Woof! This adorable 14K solid gold Salty Dog Paw Charm features STJ on the front...
Large One Love Pendant with Stone - London Blue Topaz
BEST SELLER
5 stone options
Larimar
Blue Zircon
London Blue Topaz
Green Zircon
Citrine

Large One Love Pendant with Stone

Regular price $428.00
Sale price $428.00 Regular price
Unit price
Silver & 14K Gold Accents
The One Love Pendant, with a gently hammered sterling silver infinite circle, is inspired by...
Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant - London Blue Topaz
BEST SELLER
6 stone options
Larimar
Hampton Blue Topaz
London Blue Topaz
White Zircon
Green Zircon
Citrine

Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant

Regular price $268.00
Sale price $268.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Princess Petroglyph Stone Pendant is a great addition to your jewelry collection. Handcrafted from...
Stone Cluster Drop Earrings - London Blue Topaz/Hampton Blue Topaz/White Zircon
BEST SELLER

Stone Cluster Drop Earrings

Regular price $498.00
Sale price $498.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Stone Cluster Drop Earrings feature a gently hammered sterling silver loop shape adorned with...
Palm Tree Charm

Palm Tree Charm

Regular price $348.00
Sale price $348.00 Regular price
Unit price
The Palm Tree Charm is handcrafted from 14K solid gold and features a twisted bail....
Swirling Petroglyph & Stone Bead Charm - Green Zircon
NEW
2 stone options
Blue Zircon
Green Zircon

Swirling Petroglyph & Stone Bead Charm

Regular price $149.00
Sale price $149.00 Regular price
Unit price
Sterling Silver
The Petroglyph Bead Charm is handcrafted in .925 sterling silver, featuring faceted green zircon stones...
« 1 … 3 4 5 6 7 … 9 »
Sort by
  • Featured
  • Best selling
  • Alphabetically, A-Z
  • Alphabetically, Z-A
  • Price, low to high
  • Price, high to low
  • Date, old to new
  • Date, new to old

Elevate your gift-giving with our collection of jewelry, all under $500. This selection offers sophisticated style and exceptional quality, featuring island-inspired jewelry handcrafted in sterling silver, 14K gold, oxidized silver, and stunning gemstones that are perfect for making a statement. Each piece combines timeless design with modern craftsmanship, creating gifts that are as meaningful as they are beautiful. Discover gifts that sparkle with elegance and make every moment unforgettable!